Hindsight Is 20/20: Music Reviews That Make Us Scratch Our Heads


Music journalists freak out about music. We also exist in a world where we are acutely aware of everyone else’s opinions about the newest records, or at least the buzz. This sometimes puts us in strange scenarios, like when two people who both think Yeezus is a classic album are yelling at each other because one of them “didn’t acknowledge enough of its flaws.” It’s a hazard of the job that sometimes we get a bit too caught up in this referential fantasy world and spew out some absolutely wacky journalism. Everyone is guilty of it.

Some of the most easily recognizable instances of this phenomena occur in album reviews. As early at the 1960s, Rolling Stone was perfecting the art of eviscerating records they didn’t like to the point where they couldn’t possibly believe it was an objective review. Every single Led Zeppelin album was lined up against the wall and shot. But sometimes bizarre reviews can be exactly the opposite, like when Pitchfork waxed on about how epic The Massacre was, using the word “superhero” at one point. Still other reviews seem off to us in hindsight not because the opinion presented went so hard against consensus, but because the rhetoric just got flat-out wonky (and in the case of some rap album reviews, white with a capital W).

We’ve compiled 20 album reviews that still make us scratch our heads to this day, with a bonus journalistic hiccup from Pigeons & Planes’ own past.

Continue Reading

  • Name

    But Camp was terrible…

  • http://twitter.com/#!/PancakeMcKennz pancakemckennz

    Remind me not to take any stock tips from you guys. haha

  • penda

    this article is about reviews not albums. the Camp review was ass regardless of whether or not the album was good or bad.

  • Taytay

    You guys arnt gonna make many friends writing this… i know the meaning of it though and i think its good.

  • Professor Green

    How can you forget all those anti James Blake posts P&P used to write?

  • Crunch

    I mean yeah, but 1.whatever bad? C’mon, the message would’ve been conveyed had they given it what it deserved, somewhere in the 4-5 ballpark

  • Shia

    pitchfork be like… ‘but still the nigga you love to hate, but can’t, because you love what i make’

  • Halcyon Daze

    My biggest reaction was at the review for the album Lights.Like it doesn’t even talk about the album itself but more so on how it is “impossible” for folk pop to sound good

  • Crisp

    Asher Roth COULD have been good. Don’t beat yourselves up for it. I would have agreed with you back then.

  • mic

    it was worthy of a 5-7 rating because that’s what p4k gives average records and Camp was an average record. that review was less about Camp and more about how much p4k seemed to hate Donald Glover.

Latest News