One of the best aspects of big tours is seeing what surprise guests bands have in store. Foo Fighters have been bringing out a lot of big names on their current tour, but the artist they brought out last night might be the most surprising. That’s because towards the end of their set the band invited Jewel on stage to perform. Yes, Jewel.

But that’s not even the most unexpected part. Instead of playing one of their songs, or as Dave says, “some nice thing [they] thought would sound good,” Jewel requested they cover Led Zeppelin’s “Whole Lotta Love” instead. Honestly I was ready to hate but their rendition was pretty good, especially unrehearsed.

Watch fan footage above, via Spin.