Yesterday, Arcade Fire’s album Reflektor leaked. Soon after, the band offered up a full stream of the album. It’s only been out there for one day, but people make up their minds quickly. Some listeners have already decided what they think of album, and they’re taking pretty extreme stances. The only problem? They can’t agree. If the early verdicts are any indication, Reflektor may be the band’s most polarizing album yet. Read some knee-jerk reactions below, and listen for yourself to see what you think.